Beaver County Treasurer Connie Javens and her adult daughter Renee Javens Zuk have asked a judge to allow them to update a lawsuit they filed against several anonymous commenters on the Beaver Countian. The women are seeking to submit sworn statements attesting to the harm they have allegedly suffered as a result of remarks left by the Beaver Countian’s readers.

Among the allegations made by Renne Zuk in her affidavit is that she is now under a doctor’s care and is suffering from hair loss due to stress caused by the anonymous commenters.

Affidavit of Renee Javens Zuk:

“As the result of comments posted in the Beaver Countian, I and my family (which consists of my three children that I am raising as a single mother) have endured great mental suffering, many, many sleepless nights, which has resulted in anger. These comments, such as that I am stealing taxpayers’ money and that I possess a STD, have caused great humiliation and embarrassment. I have received phone calls and numerous individuals have stopped me at supermarkets, department stores, etc., asking me why I have been targeted. I am currently under doctor’s care and am losing my hair because of all the stress. My children have (two in college and one in high school) asked me why are all of these horrible statements about me and my mother on the website.”

Affidavit of Connie T. Javens:

“These defamatory comments set forth in our Motion have caused mental anguish, sleepless nights and humiliation. Friends and family have repeatedly called me inquiring as to why I am being called names and accused of stealing money and embezzling from the County and also receiving bribes, which is a total lie. Also, I am continually being stopped at work, in the stores, banks, etc. and questioned about my conduct as Treasurer.”

Both of the affidavits also contained statements that they were being signed under oath.

A hearing is scheduled for November 14th at 2:00pm for oral arguments on motions filed by the Beaver Countian and the commenters to quash a subpoena issued by Javens and Zuk seeking information which could be used to identify the anonymous individuals.

Motion For Leave To File Plaintiffs’ Affidavits

John Paul
John Paul is the founder of the Beaver Countian. He reports full-time for the site, specializing in investigative journalism with an emphasis on public corruption.

Reader Comments

Photo and Image Files
Audio and Video Files
Other File Types
3 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
3 Comment authors
WalkweredareresRaven Recent comment authors
newest oldest top voted
Notify of

“…currently under doctor’s care and am losing my hair because of all the stress.”

“…mental anguish, sleepless nights and humiliation…”

In my opinion, these are POST FACTO, months-later, additions in answer to the most recent filing by the defense lawyers requiring “verifiable” examples of “harm.” It seems to be the PROLONGATION of the matter that is the reason for the stress. The ORIGINAL filings contained no such specific allegations of harm.

There are reasons why car accident victims should go immediately to the hospital to get checked out. Sprained necks and back problems that develop weeks later are hard to justify as being part of the original accident, days, weeks or even months earlier, and they do not hold up in court.

WHY does this matter drag on? The easiest answer to drop the whole darn thing. No harm, no foul. Get on with your lives. Nothing is to be gained from continuing it. It just gets worse.


Raven, I have always loved your postings, they are well thought and lucid statements. On a lighter note, I am glad Ms. Zuk is a hairdresser, she can do a professional comb over, saving money for her mother’s defense.


Do what most people do when stressed, go for a WALK.