Theresa Caputo Show Appearance / stock image by Donald Kravitz / Getty Images Entertainment

A reality television star who claims to be able to speak with the dead purported to communicate with Aliquippa murder victim Rachael DelTondo during a performance at Heinz Hall in Pittsburgh last Friday. Rachael’s mother Lisa was among those who paid to see Theresa Caputo, a self-proclaimed psychic medium who stars in TLC’s “Long Island Medium.”

Lisa DelTondo told she went to see Caputo’s show at the urging of her daughter’s friends.

Rachael DelTondo was murdered at the bottom of her parents’ driveway in Aliquippa on Mother’s Day. Rachael’s death has been covered by news outlets throughout the United States and abroad, but her murder has not yet been solved by the Beaver County Detectives Bureau and her killer remains on the loose.

Caputo has portrayed a medium on the TLC reality tv series since 2012 and has written two New York Times’ bestsellers, “There’s More to Life Than This,” and “You Can’t Make This Stuff Up.” She also performs in a traveling roadshow, “Theresa Caputo Live! The Experience.”

She has a large following of individuals who believe she has supernatural ability, boasting over 3.6 million fans to her Facebook page.

Lisa said the tickets cost her a small fortune because she had to buy them through a scalper, but she was desperate to get answers about who killed her daughter.

“They were marked $98, but brokers bought up all the tickets. I paid $600 to get into the front row. I could look up her dress that’s how close we were.”

Lisa took her cousin, Jackie Belcastro, along with her to the show. Lisa and Jackie were raised together as if they were sisters, and Rachael referred to Jackie as her aunt.

Lisa said some of the things Caputo began calling out to the audience during the show started to resonate with her.

“She said the number 13, she kept saying 13, and I was going to stand up because of course that’s the day Rachael was killed.”

Lisa said she kept silent as Caputo began doing readings for several other people in the audience.

“Then she said, who here is wearing something from their deceased loved one. That’s when I stood up.”

Lisa told she was wearing a coat that had belonged to her daughter, along with a lot of her jewelry. She was holding her daughter’s prayer card during the show.

“The coat didn’t fit. I couldn’t get it to zip because my daughter was so small,” said Lisa. “(Caputo) said, your daughter said to take it off because you look ridiculous.”

Lisa said it seemed like just the kind of statement Rachael would have made to her.

“I was crying ugly face,” said Lisa. “She said, mom quit praying to die because we don’t want you here, it is not your time yet.”

Lisa asked Caputo to have Rachael identify her killer, but it didn’t happen.

“She said she knows but she doesn’t want to tell you, because you and your husband could be in danger.”

Caputo assured Lisa that Rachael was telling her justice would come but she needs to be patient. Then Lisa said Caputo told her something that helped to put her at ease.

“She said I want you to know she is with you and that she is at peace. And when she said that, my heart dropped. That was all I wanted to hear — that my daughter is OK wherever she is.”

Skeptics insist that Theresa Caputo — and other high profile psychic mediums — are not actually speaking with the dead, but are instead using a technique known as “cold reading” to make individuals falsely believe they are communicating with their lost loved ones. Caputo has previously turned down offers from the James Randy Educational Foundation of $1 million if she could demonstrate her claimed abilities under scientific test conditions.

“Whether (Caputo) is full of shit, whether I believe it or not, she was amazing,” said Lisa. “I believe I felt my daughter’s spirit that night. I do believe whatever makes me Lisa, whatever made her Rachael, is still floating around somewhere … Maybe I am being stupid, I don’t know, but I think I believe in God less than I believe in Theresa Caputo.”

Jackie also said she believes that Caputo was channeling Rachael.

“Being brought up as a Catholic you don’t want to believe this, you’re not supposed to believe this,” said Jackie. “I went to Catholic school, but since this happened to Rachael I have lost my faith. I have no religion anymore. The only time I go to church is when there are special masses said for Rachael, but I’m there for her. I sit there numb, I don’t hear a word the priest says … But I thought Theresa (Caputo) was excellent. I thought it was really Rachael.”

Lisa said after the performance dozens of people who were part of the capacity crowd came up offering their support.

“When I left that place you would have thought I was Barbra Streisand. The love from strangers was just truly amazing. Everybody in the place came up to me, hugged me, telling me they were praying for me.”

Lisa said she has begun paying to schedule readings with other people who claim to have psychic abilities in hopes one of them will identify Rachael’s killer by name.

John Paul
John Paul is the founder of the Beaver Countian. He reports full-time for the site, specializing in investigative journalism with an emphasis on public corruption.

Reader Comments

Photo and Image Files
Audio and Video Files
Other File Types
15 Comment threads
8 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
20 Comment authors
TheothersidesezmeWise OwlwindTom Smith Recent comment authors
newest oldest top voted
Notify of
Wadsworth Van Quip
Wadsworth Van Quip

Wow. Some real straight-A students here in ‘ol Beaver County.

bobby boom boom
bobby boom boom

HAHAHAHAHA What are the odds that a relative of a dead person looking for answers is in the audience at one of Caputo’s psychic performance? About 1-1000?

On a sadder note, Beaver County probably hired her on the spot at $5,000 a day to bring her special brand of psychic insight to the case. “I feel that the killer was someone who had a reason to kill her…”

Write that down, detectives, we have a lead!


In addition to being called a “phony” by some of her clients, Caputo landed at the center of a full-fledged investigation in 2014 when professional whistleblower Ron Tebo, who runs, set out on her trail to prove that her ability to communicate with the deceased is a total hoax.

“Theresa is like a vulture preying on the most vulnerable,” Tebo told RadarOnline of his motivation. “I think it’s despicable.” After spending a year interviewing a slew of clients and colleagues, the investigator concluded that Caputo is simply reading body language, making high-probability guesses and relying on her assistants to pre-interview the show’s guests — not talking to the dead.

“She schmoozes with the audience, and wins them over with her big hair, designer shoes and comedy. When they trust her, she goes in for the kill,” he told the outlet. “She’ll ask the group a question like, ‘Who lost an older male relative to heart problems?’ It’s the oldest trick in the medium’s book.”

Tebo went on to speculate that, “when you purchase a ticket, you provide your full name, address and phone number to the vendor. The vendor can share this information with her staff, and then they can investigate the individual audience members. It seems she focuses on the front rows.”


The article said she bought her tickets from a scalper so they would not have get information from purchase to look into her specifically.


I believe this lady is a fake but if it helps the mother overcome the hatred in her heart that she says is all she has left, then good. Hatred eats from the inside out.


I just pray for her mom and family. And that they find the person who murdered her. What is taking so long? As far as the psychic…unless they tell me something no one else would know..I’m not believing.

Sal Governale
Sal Governale

I would give Larry Caputo a hand job.

Tom Smith
Tom Smith

Hey now!