Beaver County Treasurer Connie Javens / file photo by John Paul

Beaver County Treasurer Connie Javens violated provisions of law contained in the Pennsylvania County Code by failing to follow proper procedures when unilaterally distributing millions of dollars from county owned bank accounts to the new private owners of Friendship Ridge, but did not likely commit any crime by doing so, according to District Attorney David Lozier — Although Lozier said he has not made a final determination as to whether or not to bring criminal charges against Treasurer Javens, he strongly suggested to those who attended the Commissioners’ work session yesterday that based on his investigation to date, no charges will be forthcoming.

Several citizens attended yesterday’s meeting to ask about the status of the year-long criminal investigation into Treasurer Connie Javens and the Commissioners’ drawn-out efforts to recoup approximately $1.3 million they say the county is owed by Comprehensive Healthcare Management Services from their purchase of Friendship Ridge.

“I’ve got a question,” said Hopewell Township resident Carl Hughes during a public comments session of the meeting. “I’m glad our District Attorney is here. Are there going to be criminal prosecutions for the things that happened or are we just going to sweep this under the rug, because it didn’t take the Warren Commission this long to figure out who killed Kennedy. We hear nothing but dead silence, crickets all the time, is anybody being prosecuted? […] If you’re not going to hold the politicians to the same standards as the public you’re going to have problems […] This cozy stuff down here has got to go […] If that was me, believe me, you’d be all over me like a fly.”

District Attorney David Lozier suggested his office has found no evidence that Treasurer Javens personally profited when she violated the Pennsylvania County Code by unilaterally withdrawing millions of dollars from the bank throughout 2014 and 2015 using just her own signature. Provisions of state law forbid a County Treasurer from dispersing funds without the signatures of the Board of Commissioners and County Controller, but Lozier said that in order for a crime to be committed the county would have had to suffer a harm, which he also suggested his investigation has found no indication of.

“Let me be very clear,” said District Attorney David Lozier in response to Hughes’ question. “When I first entered office we were faced with accusations that there were improper procedures on the part of the County Treasurer in regard to the way money was transferred to the new owners of Friendship Ridge […] When you look at the records, the specific statutory procedures were not followed in the way you had to have certain signatures and certain approvals to disperse funds […] That does not make it a crime. […] A crime requires an injury or damage. What I have spent my time doing is going through all the contracts […] My office has interviewed several score witnesses, within banks, within this courthouse, prior courthouse employees, as well as people within the new and old Friendship Ridge structure.”

District Attorney Lozier said that he was going to wait until the county finishes resolving its contract dispute with Friendship Ridge before making a final determination on whether or not to bring any criminal charges.

“That’s being civilly litigated and I’m watching that at the same time to make sure the result of my investigation matches the forensic audit,” said Lozier. “At the appropriate time I will make a decision, but again, just because a precise procedure was not followed does not mean that the county lost a penny. It’s a matter of whether the correct funds were transferred. It doesn’t mean there’s anything missing just because the actual approvals weren’t made.”

Carl Hughes pressed back, “But the evading of the proper procedure to have 2 signatures or 3 signatures from the Commissioners, is that not a crime?”

“It’s a violation of procedure, the law requires an actual injury,” said Lozier. “What you are talking about is a corruption charge, under the corruption charge just because you violate procedures doesn’t mean it’s a crime if the person who is violating procedures doesn’t specifically profit from the violation.”

“She was quite aware of what was required,” said Hughs. “There can be only one reason why you go outside of the system.”

Carl Hughes and other members of the public were not the only people in attendance at yesterday’s meeting who challenged District Attorney Lozier’s statements. County Financial Administrator Ricardo Luckow, who is a Certified Public Accountant, also questioned any assertion that no harm was done.

“I just have a question. I am bit confused now, between what you said [County Solicitor Andrea Cantelmi], the county’s position is that Friendship Ridge owes us money, right,” asked Luckow.

“Correct,” said Cantelmi.

“And you [District Attorney David Lozier] said there needs to be harm for it to become a crime, wouldn’t that be the harm,” asked Luckow.

District Attorney Lozier responded, “Not necessarily when you’re talking about a civil contract […] It’s normal after a contract like that to come up to the end and to audit the contract and figure out who owes what based on monies that went back and forth. What I’m looking at, as you’re well aware, is whether or not any money improperly changed hands by the procedure that was used in the withdrawals for Friendship Ridge and whether there was any crime that occurred at that point, and if it was someone that used an improper procedure did that person benefit from that.”

Following the meeting, the Beaver Countian asked District Attorney Lozier if lucrative contracts obtained by the adult children of an elected official could constitute personal benefit as defined by law.

“I would have to prove that there was a direct quid pro quo,” responded the District Attorney.

The investigation into Treasurer Connie Javens was originally being conducted by the Pennsylvania State Police, but District Attorney Lozier “fired” them in March of last year, saying he wanted his own County Detectives to conduct the investigation instead.

Treasurer Connie Javens currently has a defamation lawsuit pending against several commenters on the Beaver Countian who criticized her unilateral bank withdrawals for Friendship Ridge and the contracts her family members negotiated with the new owners of the facility. Although the Beaver Countian is not a named defendant in the lawsuit, this publication has refused to comply with a subpoena issued by Javens seeking information which could enable her to discover the true identities of the anonymous individuals.

John Paul
John Paul is the founder of the Beaver Countian. He reports full-time for the site, specializing in investigative journalism with an emphasis on public corruption.

288
Reader Comments

avatar
Photo and Image Files
 
 
 
Audio and Video Files
 
 
 
Other File Types
 
 
 
193 Comment threads
95 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
50 Comment authors
Richard DaleyskinseconomyresidentHogBeaverNewbie Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest top voted
Notify of
Joe Keyser
Guest
Joe Keyser

Cover up business as usual

Ron Scherfel
Guest
Ron Scherfel

Biggest crook in beaver county

Martina
Guest
Martina

And Controller Rossi just sits there

Elle Han
Guest
Elle Han

I am sure that I don’t have all of the facts – so I can’t make any accusations, but Connie Javens has been the treasurer for quite a long time. In all of that time (25 years) she never learned that she needs the County Controllers signature in order to disburse funds? I think someone needs to do some more digging for facts. On the other hand, she could just be a very slow learner.

Wendy Smith
Guest
Wendy Smith

How do you violate the law without committing a crime? I really don’t understand this.

Leslie Flara
Guest
Leslie Flara

This was my exact question…. Wonder how many criminals will say the same thing? I broke the law but didn’t do anything criminal!!!! Lol

thomas dishler
Guest
thomas dishler

Hard to understand sounds like talking in circles to me. If someone pulls a gun on someone points it and walks away is that not a crime but no one was hurt so does that means it is ok

Jared Weidner
Guest
Jared Weidner

Ask Hillary she knows a thing or two about this.

rick
Member
rick

Hillary knows way more about how to take care of herself.

Michael Muhammad
Guest
Michael Muhammad

Jared Weidner you one stupid inbred

Eddie Taylor
Guest
Eddie Taylor

Michael Muhammad how?

Jared Weidner
Guest
Jared Weidner

Michael Muhammad – you’re

snake2872
Guest
snake2872

Apparent neither does the District Attorney!

Bill Atwell
Guest
Bill Atwell

She violated the law but did not commit a crime? Is this a oxymoron? Or you playing with us? This man has a law degree?

A violation of law is a crime. So why is she not being charged? Maybe we the people need the state AG or maybe the US Attorney for Western Pa come in and really exam every county row office and start charging them with RICO and other federal laws.

Wendy Smith
Guest
Wendy Smith

I’m not impressed with the US Attorney General’s office either though.

Bill Atwell
Guest
Bill Atwell

I’m not impressed with anything I am seeing in this county. Tired of my tax dollars being waisted. Tired of the politicians in this county act like they are doing me a favor by taking my money. They work for us. I don’t work for them.

The whole row offices need revamped

ricimer
Guest
ricimer

Da lozier is calling everyone in BC idiots. At that meeting DA lozier gave a fine example of legalize double talk BULLSHIT. At the very least hes guilty of aiding and abetting.

Sean McClain
Guest
Sean McClain

Why is an agency OUTSIDE of the corrupt Beaver Co. Government not doing this audit and investigation….seems like a huge Conflict ….. disgusting they keep getting away with robbing us all … when will the state step in and fix this crap

Mary A Kurtz
Guest
Mary A Kurtz

I believe at one time the State Police were involved but someone in the commissioner team had that changed…It’s been a sticky mess because they know she did wrong..Next thing you know someone will announce she has an illness or something to continue covering it up

bobb
Member
bobb

Mary, I believe that it was DA Loziar that decided the State Police wouldn’t investigate.