A Baden Councilwoman says she was surprised and confused when called as part of a phone vote to hire part-time police for the town, and alleges other members of Council have intentionally excluded her from similar phone votes conducted in the past.

Councilwoman Suzie Furr told the Beaver Countian that she voted against hiring part-time police at the town’s January 17th public meeting because she wanted more time to research the issue.

“In my mind, I wanted to figure out what would be the best way to hire,” said Furr, “another full-time officer or keep going on and on and on with all of these part-timers.”

Furr said although she had voted to table the matter for a month, she received a phone call from the town’s secretary two days later telling her she was taking a phone vote on the hiring of part-time police.

“The secretary called me about this phone vote but she did not say who it was directed by,” said Furr. “I was confused, the thing was we discussed it at the previous Council meeting and said it would be taken up at the next meeting.”

Councilwoman Furr said she voted “Yes” believing it to be an affirmative vote to keep the matter tabled until February, “I thought I voted to keep it tabled because we specified we would wait until February’s meeting to do the hiring.”

She later learned her “Yes” vote was actually recorded as being in favor of approving the hires immediately.

Furr said this was not the first time Baden Council conducted votes privately via telephone instead of during a public meeting and that she has previously been excluded from those votes.

“I am usually not even called on these phone votes that’s why I was surprised,” said Furr. “They have their block, the majority, and I was never included which really upset me.”

The Pennsylvania Sunshine Act generally mandates votes of a Borough Council occur at publicly advertised meetings and that members of the public be allowed to make comment prior to votes taking place.

See Also:

Baden Borough Stalling Release Of Public Records – Sources Allege Council Hired Police In Secret Vote

Baden Councilman Says He Objected To A Private Phone Vote To Hire Police

Baden Borough Stalls Release Of Additional Public Records So It Can “Assess The Cost Of The Request”

John Paul
John Paul is the founder of the Beaver Countian. He reports full-time for the site, specializing in investigative journalism with an emphasis on public corruption.

Reader Comments

Photo and Image Files
Audio and Video Files
Other File Types
14 Comment threads
11 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
11 Comment authors
John Q TaxpayergringoGreg HetrickCHEAP SEATSGetitright Recent comment authors
newest oldest top voted
Notify of

They should not have phone votes.

ET Phone Home
ET Phone Home

How the hell is that (secret phone votes) even legal?!

Tom Setzer
Tom Setzer

These are not. Read the other related stories.

John Q Taxpayer
John Q Taxpayer

So the secretary is conducting this orchestra? The only one that is getting paid a wage that she depends on to support her family. She is the only one that really has anything to lose. They put her in the hot seat now!


It sounds like the epitome of laziness to me, Ms. Furr. Not only did you agree to an unconventional phone vote, you know that it has happened before. Your vote was amidst confusion in your mind. You could’ve have said that and refused to vote at all. Speak up; don’t just go along. Were you hoping to stay in favor with the majority? Also,how are these phone votes recorded in the minutes? This one sure sounds sneaky, especially after the vote to table.