Ambridge Civil Service Member Beats Back Calls For Resignation

Ambridge Civil Service Member Beats Back Calls For Resignation


A member of the Ambridge Civil Service Commission beat back calls for his resignation last night at the Borough’s public meeting of Council.

Several residents in attendance at the meeting called for Richard Heitzenrater’s resignation, after it was revealed the town had been denied a $200,000 grant by the United State Department of Justice because Ambridge Council appointed the former police sergeant to its Civil Service Commission.

In November of 2010, Richard Heitzenrater was sentenced by a federal judge to serve 6 months in a halfway-house, 6 months on house arrest, and 6 months of probation for Civil Rights violations and destruction of evidence to cover up his 2009 beating of a man in police custody. Ambridge Borough settled a subsequent lawsuit filed against the town by Heitzenrater’s victim for a reported $150,000.

Heitzenrater did not offer to resign from the Civil Service Committee last night, and several members of council defended his appointment. “I was involved in law enforcement for 33 years and I made one mistake,” Heitzenrater was quoted as saying by the Times at last night’s meeting.

Research by the Beaver Countian reveals the Borough had paid out at least two additional settlements to individuals who alleged they had been beaten by Heitzenrater through the years.

Back in 1997, Thomas Graziani alleged Heitzenrater was directing traffic when his driver’s side mirror bumped the officer’s flashlight. Graziani alleged Heitzenrater began swearing at him and punching him on his head before yanking him onto the pavement. The borough settled with that man for $30,000.

Philip Grzegorek alleged he was beaten in a holding cell of the Ambridge Police Station back in 2001 while he was handcuffed. Grzegorek alleged that attack involved three officers, led by Heitzenrater. The man was reportedly left in a coma for 3 days following the incident. The borough settled with that man for $50,000.

Heitzenrater was not criminally charged in connection with either of those two alleged incidents, the Borough and Officers all denied any wrongdoing as part of the settlements.

Court documents reviewed by the Beaver Countian allude to still another possible settlement made by Ambridge Borough, also for $50,000, involving additional allegations of police brutality on the part of Heitzenrater. This publication was unable to locate any documents detailing that alleged incident.

Ambridge Council members Duke McCoy, Tony Cafarelli, Janet Caldarelli, Bob Dunn, Michael Mikulich, and Joe Pucci, voted unanimously in 2012 to appoint Richard Heitzenrater to a six year term on its Civil Service Commission. The three-person Commission is responsible for overseeing the hiring process for police officers in the Borough, and can decide appeals of any disciplinary action taken against officers in accordance with civil service laws.

Richard Heitzenrater is running as a Republican for a seat on Borough Council in the municipal elections on November 5th.

Help Us Deliver This Story To Other Readers:

Other Headlines

US Drug Enforcement Administration: Beaver County Official Didn’t Return Our Phone Calls Beaver County is one of just five counties in Pennsylvania that failed to cooperate with a United States Drug Enforcement Administration's 67-county s...
Man’s $20,000+ Bid To Unseat Judge Deborah Kunselman Was Unsuccessful But Had An Impact A wealthy businessman who ran a lone campaign seeking to unseat Beaver County Judge Deborah Kunselman spent over $20,000 in his failed attempt to conv...
County Paralegal And Former Sheriff’s Deputy Both Waive Preliminary Hearings – Sign Plea... County Paralegal Dionna Steele and former Sheriff's Deputy Erica Bacon waived their rights to preliminary hearings this week and signed plea agreement...

About The Author

Profile photo of John Paul

John Paul is a Beaver County native and the founder of the Beaver Countian. He reports full-time for the site, specializing in investigative journalism with an emphasis on public corruption.


  1. jaacee

    Only in Beaver County can a friggen ex-con be on the police civil service board. If Beaver County had control, Maddof would be appointed Secretary of the Treasury.

  2. lol

    Hey hietzy hours is that council race?

    tony and duke got it under control

    wait your on republican ticket ohhh social circumstances that doesn’t matter

    yeah that board real smart hire chief before New board gets in hmmmm hour it wasn’t long term contact?

    Oh hell you guys got cash you just fucked yourself on a grant for 300k didn’t matter Jimmy will write new grant? duke will lobby?

  3. a real regular guy

    UNBELIEVABLE…Only in Ambridge, can they piss away 300K and still stand behind the convict that cost them the money. What is more important to the council, keeping Heitzie as a buddy, or doing what’s right for the Boro. Looks like its time to vote out this council, but don’t just vote Republican, because then you’ll elect the convict that cost them the 300K


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *