Sunday, October 25, 2020
38.6 F
Sunday, October 25, 2020
38.6 F

Preliminary Hearing For Sheldon Jeter Jr. Postponed Over Defense Attorney’s Objection

A scheduled hearing today for a man accused of the May 15 killing of Tyric Pugh in Aliquippa has been continued.

Sheldon Devant Jeter, Jr., 22, of Aliquippa, is facing criminal homicide charges for allegedly shooting and killing Pugh. Speaking to through his attorney, Jeter has denied the accusation.

The preliminary hearing in the case has been continued until June 25 at the request of prosecutors, who say they are awaiting final forensic reports that have been backlogged due to COVID-19 related delays.

Senior Magisterial District Judge John Armor approved the continuance over the objections of attorney Michael Santicola, who is representing Jeter in the case.

“My objection was, if you need forensic reports to sustain a prima facie case at a preliminary hearing you shouldn’t have charged him,” Santicola said.

While “proof beyond a reasonable doubt” is the familiar standard for trials, preliminary hearings require only some evidence be presented to establish each of the material elements of a crime, and to establishes probable cause to believe the accused committed the offense — a standard known to attorneys as “prima facie.”

Continue reading the rest of this article by becoming a subscriber. Your support makes our local reporting in Beaver County possible.
Subscribe Now! Log In
John Paul
John Paul
John Paul is an award-winning investigative journalist and founder of He reports full-time for the site with a focus on public watchdog journalism.

Reader Comments:

Latest News

Commissioners Gave $1.8 Million In COVID Relief Funds To These 110 Companies

Beaver County has awarded $1.84 million to 110 companies that applied for relief under the CARES Act (Coronavirus Aid,...

Baden Council Abruptly Ended Public Meeting Because The Public Showed Up

Baden Borough Council abruptly ended its public meeting Wednesday night because members of the public showed up to it. Residents gathered after learning on social...

Jury Finds Ambridge Police Chief Not Guilty Of All Charges

Ambridge Police Chief James Mann has been found not guilty of all ten felony and misdemeanor charges filed against him by state police. Prosecutors...

Sources: President Trump Cancels Unannounced Visit To Ambridge In Beaver County

President Donald J. Trump's reelection campaign has canceled a visit to Ambridge Borough in Beaver County, according to two sources familiar with planning for...

Courthouse Controversy As Treasurer Calls Out Commissioners And Controller Chastises Camp

The Beaver County Board of Commissioners used secret codes during a public work session Wednesday when discussing resolutions they planned to vote on this...
error: Alert: Content is protected!