An Aliquippa school director and her son have been arrested by the Pennsylvania Attorney General’s Office and are awaiting trial on allegations they engaged in a criminal conspiracy to defraud a car insurance company.
Catherine L. Colalella, 44, of Aliquippa, was arrested March 18 by state agents on felony counts of insurance fraud, conspiracy to commit insurance fraud, and criminal attempt of theft by deception, according to court documents.
Colalella’s son, Thomas J. Shaw, 20, also of Aliquippa, is facing the same charges.
According to a criminal complaint filed by agents with the Attorney General’s Insurance Fraud Section, Shaw was driving Colalella’s 2018 Chevy Traverse at about 8:05 a.m., November 7, 2020, when he “lost control of the vehicle” and crashed into a telephone pole.
You've started reading a story you won't find anywhere else. We rely on engaged citizens like you to hold local power accountable and uncover the truth.
LOCAL GOVERNMENT DOESN'T WATCH ITSELF
That's what we're here for. We investigate the people and institutions making decisions that affect your family, your community and your tax dollars.
$20 A Month – Cancel Online At Any Time

