PA Supreme Court Issues Dual Rulings In Jeter Jr. Murder Conviction

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has declined to hear an appeal filed by convicted killer Sheldon Jeter Jr., but in a rare move, has agreed to hear one filed by his prosecutors. The high-stakes hearing before the high court could cement Jeter’s murder conviction.

A jury found Jeter guilty in June 2021 of first-degree murder for the Aliquippa shooting death of his close friend, Tyric Pugh.

The Beaver County District Attorney’s Office has also named Jeter as their suspect in the 2018 Mother’s Day killing of school teacher Rachael DelTondo of Aliquippa. Jeter has denied any involvement in her murder and Beaver County Detectives have not made an arrest.

Subscriber Story

Read the rest of this article.

Subscribe to keep reading Beaver Countian’s exclusive reporting — and help fund the investigations that make it possible.

✓ Access All We Offer
✓ Fund Our Investigations
✓ Read Ad-Free

Go Unlimited →

John Paul
John Paul
John Paul is an award-winning investigative journalist and founder of BeaverCountian.com. He's been profiled by Vanity Fair magazine and featured in thousands of news articles, tv shows, and books. An avid adventurer, JP has traveled to all 50 states in his journey to explore our country and its people.

Latest News

Connie Javens – First Woman To Serve As County Treasurer – Dead At 88

Constance "Connie" Tuccinard Javens, who broke barriers as the first woman elected Beaver County Treasurer, died Tuesday, August 18,...